Climate action could halve energy firms' worth - bank


The San Ardo oil field in Monterey County, Calif. A study from a bank warns the investment sector that oil companies face huge loses if the world cuts carbon emissions enough to limit global warming. Photo by Steve Wilson/flickr.

Feb. 2, 2013

If the world succeeds in reaching its targets for curbing greenhouse gases, a leading bank says huge quantities of oil and gas reserves must be left unused.

By Alex Kirby
Climate News Network

LONDON – Oil and gas multinationals could lose up to 60 percent of their market value if the world cuts its carbon emissions to limit climate change, according to the world's second-largest bank.

This is the first time the financial sector has been warned by one of its own that shares could plummet.

This is the first time the financial sector has been warned by one of its own that shares could plummet if the necessary action is taken to prevent disaster.

The study, Oil and Carbon Revisited: Value At Risk From 'Unburnable' Reserves, is published by HSBC Global Research.

The International Energy Agency said in its 2012 World Energy Outlook that to have a 50 percent chance of limiting the rise in global temperatures to 2° Celsius, only a third of current fossil fuel reserves can be burned before 2050.

Staying within the 2°C limit would mean keeping carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere to 450 parts per million. They are already at 390 ppm, and are increasing by about 2 ppm a year.

Crossing the boundary

To stop them crossing the 450 ppm boundary, scientists say the world can add only around 1,440 gigatonnes of carbon to the atmosphere between now and mid-century. It has already emitted 400 Gt, leaving only around 1,000 Gt in the budget – one-third of current proven oil and gas reserves.

The 2°C target has been the goal of many policymakers for years, although there is a growing scientific consensus that it is already out of reach.

The World Bank has said that the Earth may warm by as much as 4°C, and some predictions suggest that even a 6°C rise is possible – a prospect whose impacts would be devastating, scientists broadly agree.

The economic impact on parts of the hydrocarbon industry of exploiting only a third of fossil fuel reserves would be devastating.

The HSBC study says the economic impact on parts of the hydrocarbon industry of exploiting only a third of fossil fuel reserves would also be devastating.

Unburnable reserves

The Norwegian company Statoil would be hardest hit, with 17 percent of its reserves unburnable. The study says about 6 percent of BP's reserves are at risk, 5 percent of Total's and 2 percent of Shell's.

But it says a bigger risk is that reduced demand for fossil fuels could force down oil and gas prices, meaning that between 40 and 60 percent of leading fossil fuel firms' current market capitalization – essentially their net worth – could be at risk.

The study's authors say: "We believe that investors have yet to price in such a risk, perhaps because it seems so long-term.

"And we accept that our scenario probably exaggerates the risk as we assume a low-carbon world today rather than beyond 2020."

Risky oil sands

They advise investors to focus on companies with low-cost projects, and say they think capital intensive, high-cost projects like heavy oil and oil sands will be the riskiest.

The HSBC authors' argument that much of the world's fossil fuel reserves cannot be used if climate change is to be tackled seriously is not new: it has been advanced by scientists and conservationists for years.

What is striking is that this appears to be the first time the argument has been made by the financial sector itself. Said James Leaton of Carbon Tracker: "The question this raises for investors is this: Is this investment compatible with a 2°C world?"

Added Andrew Simms, a fellow of the New Economics Foundation: "I wonder whether this will wake us up from the strange spellbound state that has persisted since the Copenhagen climate summit in 2009?

"We haven't forgotten climate change, but we have forgotten that we have to do something about it." 

Alex Kirby is a founding journalist of Climate News Network and a former BBC environment correspondent. Climate News Network is a journalism news service led by four veteran British environmental reporters and broadcasters. It delivers news and commentary about climate change for free to media outlets worldwide. 


The Daily Climate is an independent, foundation-funded news service covering climate change. Contact editor Douglas Fischer at dfischer [at]


  Find more Daily Climate stories in the TDC Newsroom

Creative Commons License

 This work by The Daily Climate is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.

 Based on a work at

 Recent coverage