Pennsylvania Superior Court rules that fracking natural gas from a neighboring property is trespassing

Pennsylvania Superior Court rules that fracking natural gas from a neighboring property is trespassing

Landmark ruling could open the door to "hundreds of trespass lawsuits"

On Monday the Pennsylvania Superior Court issued an opinion that could have major ramifications for the hydraulic fracturing industry in the state: It states a company trespassed on a family's land by extracting natural gas from beneath their property while operating a fracking well next door.


The Briggs family owns about 11 acres of land in Harford Township in Susquehanna County. When Southwestern Energy began operating an unconventional natural gas well on the adjacent property in 2011, the Briggs declined to lease their mineral rights to the company for development. In 2015, they filed a complaint that Southwestern was trespassing by extracting gas from beneath their property without a lease.

Southwestern didn't dispute they'd removed natural gas from beneath the Briggs' land, but argued they weren't trespassing due to the "rule of capture," which says the first person to "capture" a natural resource like groundwater, gas or oil owns it, regardless of property lines.

A lower court agreed with Southwestern and issued a summary judgement in their favor, but yesterday's Superior Court opinion overturns that decision, stating that the rule of capture shouldn't apply to unconventional natural gas drilling because of key differences in the method of extraction.

"Unlike oil and gas originating in a common reservoir, natural gas, when trapped in a shale formation, is non-migratory in nature," the opinion states. "Shale gas does not merely 'escape' to adjoining land absent the application of an external force. Instead, the shale must be fractured through the process of hydraulic fracturing; only then may the natural gas contained in the shale move freely through the 'artificially created channel[s].'"

Ultimately, the Court said, "In light of the distinctions between hydraulic fracturing and conventional gas drilling, we conclude that the rule of capture does not preclude liability for trespass due to hydraulic fracturing."

The case has now been remanded to a lower court, which will rule on whether the Briggs are entitled to compensation from Southwestern Energy for trespassing on their property by taking natural gas without a lease. In the meantime, the family has been given the opportunity to further develop their trespass claim, including getting estimates of how far the subsurface fractures and fracking fluid crossed boundary lines into the subsurface of their property.

"I think this potentially has big ramifications for both drilling companies and property owners," said David E. Hess, the director of policy and communications for Harrisburg-based government affairs law firm Crisci Associates and former secretary of the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection.

"If on remand the case requires compensation of the adjacent landowner for trespass as defined in the court decision, I think this could open the door to hundreds of potential similar trespass lawsuits filed all across Pennsylvania where unconventional gas well drilling occurs."

Hess pointed out it's hard to find an area in Pennsylvania's shale patch where existing natural gas extraction leases don't come up against property belonging to other landowners who didn't sell their mineral rights. He also speculated that before this ruling changes the way hydraulic fracturing operates in the state, there would likely be an attempt to clarify the law.

"I think if people perceive this as a threat to the industry," Hess said, "we'll soon see legislative attempts to redefine the rule of capture in Pennsylvania."

Monday's Superior Court opinion differs from similar cases in other states.

Referencing a case in Texas where the fracking company won (Coastal Oil & Gas Corp. v. Garza Energy Trust), the Pennsylvania Superior Court noted in Monday's ruling, "we are not persuaded by the Coastal Oil Court's rationale that a landowner can adequately protect his interests by drilling his own well to prevent drainage to an adjoining property. Hydraulic fracturing is a costly and highly specialized endeavor, and the traditional recourse to 'go and do likewise' is not necessarily readily available for an average landowner."

The Court also noted that applying the rule of capture to hydraulic fracturing is problematic, since it would allow companies to extract natural gas from anywhere without the need for a lease as long as they could set up a fracking well on an adjacent property.

Hess noted that Pennsylvania's laws are unique, so what's happened with regard to the rule of capture and hydraulic fracturing in other states is unlikely to impact how things play out here.

"I think this is going to be an important decision," he said, "but I think people will be chewing on this opinion for a long time to fully understand what it means."

The flag of the Department of Homeland Security featuring a flying eagle grasping a branch and arrows in its claws.

Texas floods reignite fight over FEMA and weather cuts

Catastrophic floods in central Texas have deepened partisan divides in Congress, with Democrats accusing President Trump’s administration of weakening the country’s ability to prevent and respond to natural disasters.

Andres Picon reports for E&E News.

Keep reading...Show less
A burned classic truck sitting in a burned forest.

California faces growing disaster costs as Trump moves to scale back FEMA aid

As California rebuilds from its deadliest wildfire season in years, state officials warn that President Trump’s proposed cuts to Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) aid could leave communities without the support they need to recover.

Jeremy Lindenfeld reports for Capital & Main.

Keep reading...Show less
Scientist using pipette to place liquid into containers.
Credit: National Cancer Institute/Unsplash

EPA union demands reinstatement of staff punished for calling out political interference

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency staff who criticized Trump-era rollbacks are now on forced leave, sparking claims of illegal retaliation.

Leah Douglas reports for Reuters.

Keep reading...Show less
white airplane flying under the blue sky

Zeldin releases EPA data on contrails and solar geoengineering amid Texas flood backlash

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Lee Zeldin pledged to release internal data on weather-modification technologies after conspiracies surged in the wake of deadly Texas flooding.

Kevin Bogardus and Ellie Borst report for E&E News.

Keep reading...Show less
person with umbrella walking on road between green grass field during daytime.

Climate change is disrupting South Asia’s monsoon and raising flood risks

Erratic monsoon rains driven by climate change are fueling deadly floods, landslides, and glacial lake overflows across South Asia.

Sibi Arasu reports for The Associated Press.

Keep reading...Show less
An Amazon village on the edge of a river.

Massive Amazon raids disrupt illegal mining, logging, and wildlife trafficking networks

More than 1,500 officers from four countries carried out sweeping raids in the Amazon Basin, arresting 94 people and seizing over $64 million in assets linked to environmental crime.

Steven Grattan reports for The Associated Press.

Keep reading...Show less
Electricity grid towers stretching across fields into the distance.

Europe’s power grid upgrades fall €250 billion short as demand surges

Europe’s top electricity grid operators face a massive funding gap as they race to expand and modernize infrastructure needed to meet rising demand, a new report warns.

Nina Chestney reports for Reuters.

Keep reading...Show less
From our Newsroom
Multiple Houston-area oil and gas facilities that have violated pollution laws are seeking permit renewals

Multiple Houston-area oil and gas facilities that have violated pollution laws are seeking permit renewals

One facility has emitted cancer-causing chemicals into waterways at levels up to 520% higher than legal limits.

Regulators are underestimating health impacts from air pollution: Study

Regulators are underestimating health impacts from air pollution: Study

"The reality is, we are not exposed to one chemical at a time.”

Pennsylvania governor Josh Shapiro speaks with the state flag and American flag behind him.

Two years into his term, has Gov. Shapiro kept his promises to regulate Pennsylvania’s fracking industry?

A new report assesses the administration’s progress and makes new recommendations

silhouette of people holding hands by a lake at sunset

An open letter from EPA staff to the American public

“We cannot stand by and allow this to happen. We need to hold this administration accountable.”

wildfire retardants being sprayed by plane

New evidence links heavy metal pollution with wildfire retardants

“The chemical black box” that blankets wildfire-impacted areas is increasingly under scrutiny.

Stay informed: sign up for The Daily Climate newsletter
Top news on climate impacts, solutions, politics, drivers. Delivered to your inbox week days.