Pruitt Punditry/Weekend Reader for Sunday, April 15

Pruitt Punditry/Weekend Reader for Sunday, April 15

What's the conventional wisdom from DC on Scott Pruitt's survival?

The wisdom is all over the map.


The embattled EPA Administrator is averaging a new scandal every couple of days. He's also gotten a strong vote of confidence from President Trump—just like a dozen other former Trump appointees who soon vanished into the Bermuda Triangle of the administrative branch.

So is Pruitt a short-timer, or is he in for the long run -- a boon for both polluting industries and late-night TV comics? Is he staying put, or headed for private life? Or will he be bumped up to the Attorney General's slot? Or dispatched to a Federal penitentiary?

The prospects are intriguing. The allegations against Pruitt for lavish spending and other ethical transgressions are serious -- certainly far more so than Health and Human Services Secretary Tom Price or Veterans Affairs Secretary David Shulkin, both of whom were forced out by Trump.

But Pruitt enjoys something of a Golden Boy status with President Trump for his zealous pursuit of the dismantling of his own agency. He came to Washington after seven years as Oklahoma Attorney General. His tenure was marked by repeated lawsuits against the agency he now runs. Shortly after arriving, Pruitt began to dismantle environmental regulations even as he ran roughshod over the rules for his own conduct.

This week, five Democratic members of Congress sent a six-page letter to Pruitt, demanding answers for his travel, his overpriced office decor, and his alleged persecution of employees who asked questions. Much of their curiosity was based on information from whistleblower Kevin Chmielewski, a registered Republican and Trump supporter who served as Pruitt's Deputy Chief of Staff until finding himself on unpaid administrative leave.

In March, Pruitt received a similar letter from Republican Trey Gowdy, who chairs the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform. Gowdy, who is leaving office after this Congressional term, is best known for his multi-year pursuit of Hillary Clinton's handling of the deaths of four U.S. personnel at the Consulate in Benghazi, Libya. Gowdy sent a followup letter this week saying Pruitt's office has not supplied all the info he requested. The EPA's in-house Inspector General and the Government Accountability Office are also auditing Pruitt's questionable expenses. A summary of all can be found in this Vox.com story.

At The Intercept, Sharon Lerner tracked Pruitt's similarly extravagant spending while he was Oklahoma AG.

President Trump's options with Pruitt are the object of much speculation and punditry, and it's all over the map.

Option One: Kick him upstairs. Pruitt's ambition for the Attorney General's job is nearly as well-known as is Trump's disdain for the incumbent, Jeff Sessions. Value-added for Trump is that as A.G., Pruitt would be unencumbered by recusal. Sessions triggered Trump's wrath and public disdain by recusing himself from the investigation of possible collusion by the Trump Administration in Russia's attempts to influence the 2016 election.

Why this is increasingly unlikely: Simply stated, Pruitt is damaged goods. At least three Republican Senators -- Susan Collins of Maine, Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and John Kennedy of Louisiana—have criticized Pruitt, complicating his prospects for Senate confirmation as A.G.

Option Two: Keep him on. Pruitt's EPA conduct has received more attention from the Washington press corps than, say, protecting the environment ever would. Political commentators who don't know a PCB from a PPM from a PM2.5 are tongue wagging on this one for now. But it's a storm that could blow over -- not a Stormy. And Trump really, really likes Pruitt's clear-cut style.

Option Three: Security will take you to your vehicle now, Mr. Pruitt. That would be Mr. Pruitt's greatly-expanded security detail. He's diverted investigative staff to guard him, insisted on first-class air travel for the dubious notion that it keeps him protected from murderous enviros, and installed a bizarre "cone of silence" in his office for secure phonecalls.

With both parties and potentially both houses of Congress following the lead of journalists in investigating the EPA boss, this is increasingly likely. But here, no pun intended, is a Trump card. On Thursday, the Senate approved the nomination of Andrew Wheeler to serve as Pruitt's top deputy. Wheeler is a former coal lobbyist and, like his boss, a staunch climate denier who could slide into the top job should Pruitt depart, willingly or otherwise.

Then there's this: In an apparent bureaucratic hallucination, Pruitt reportedly told a staffer that he thought the EPA logo, which features a 1970's-vintage stylized flower, reminded him of a marijuana leaf. Sources familar with marijuana leaves told me that smoking all the weed in the world could not possibly make the EPA logo look like a marijuana leaf.

Top Weekend News

Saturday's March for Science drew smaller crowds than the 2017 event, but once again, the marchers came through with first-rate signs.

A new documentary, "What Lies Upstream," tells the story of the 2014 MCHM spill that shut down the water supply for 300,000 West Virginians.

From Damian Carrington in The Guardian: Scientists warn that disruption of the ocean heat "conveyor belt" must be avoided at all costs.

Running out of options to prevent a repeat of the 2014 algae crisis in Lake Erie, Ohio Governor Kasich looks to tighten restrictions on farmers.

A Massachusetts court has greenlighted the state AG's effort to find out what Exxon knew, and when Exxon knew it, on climate change. (Inside Climate News)

From futurist.com: Beaches are one more thing we stand to lose to climate change.

Yale e360 asks, are diesel cars on the way out in Europe?

Opinions and Editorials

We've compiled a sampling of editorial views on Scott Pruitt's travails.

On this week's ,Living on Earth,Peter Dykstra and host Steve Curwood discuss how albatrosses may be used as spies on deep-sea illegal fishing; the horrific toll among park rangers protecting Virunga's mountain gorillas; and how Mother Nature helped prompt a nine-year pause in the medieval Hundred Years' War.

In a Washington Post op-ed, Gordon Davidson argues that the proposed Atlantic Coast Pipeline holds risks for both Virginia's economy and its clean energy development.

The Week in Trump rollbacks

The Interior Department's Inspector General says the Department failed to keep records of thirty controversial employee reassignments. (ABC News)

From Darryl Fears and Dino Grandoni in the Washington Post: The Trump Administration marks the 100th anniversary of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act by clipping its wings.

Setback for frackers

The Seneca Nation is celebrating the rejection of a permit to construct a fracking wastewater treatment plant near the headwaters of Pennsylvania's Allegheny River.

How climate change is being fought by assisted migration and foresters

Foresters responding to climate change are experimenting with planting trees in Vermont that typically are found further south. They hope the trees will survive hotter and drier conditions to come.
Sunrise in the woods

Get our Good News newsletter

Get the best positive, solutions-oriented stories we've seen on the intersection of our health and environment, FREE every Tuesday in your inbox. Subscribe here today. Keep the change tomorrow.

Carbon pollution pushed environmental breakdown to record levels in 2021

People have warped the climate so much that in 2021 four critical measures of planetary health broke records. Oceans grew hotter, higher and more acidic than ever documented, said the World Meteorological Organization.
New Mexico wildfire 2022
USFS/Calf Canyon-Hermits Peak/Facebook

Governor: Fire could destroy over 1,000 New Mexico homes

In a news conference Tuesday, Lujan Grisham acknowledged she did not have hard figures — most recent estimates had put losses of homes at 366 — but added “given the nature of this fire … I don’t think it’s an exaggeration.”

orphaned oil well grants for Louisiana
Louisiana DNR

Louisiana enacts new orphan oil well law to fetch $200 million in federal money

Legislation that positions Louisiana to receive an estimated $200 million in federal grants to fix orphan oil wells became law Tuesday.

Artists organize to offer new visions for tackling climate change

Recently, the Pew Research Center found that over 66 per cent of Canadians are not only concerned about the climate crisis, but willing to alter how they live to help fight it.

Pennsylvania is vying for a clean energy hub, but some worry it still relies on fossil fuels

Pennsylvania officials want to bring more energy and manufacturing jobs to the state by building a Clean Hydrogen Hub in the region.

'Flash droughts' are Midwest's next big climate threat

Fast-moving droughts are developing more and more quickly as climate change pushes temperatures to new extremes.

From our Newsroom
environmental justice

Op-Ed: Black gold and the color line

How historical racist redlining practices are linked to higher exposures to oil and gas wells.

Our mothers' gifts: Readers respond

Our mothers' gifts: Readers respond

We asked you to share one "big lesson" your mother gave. And you responded

Lake Mead

Dykstra: A corpse in a barrel in a drying reservoir

And other climate change tales for our age

A mother's gift

Gifts from our mothers

What one "big gift" did your mother give you? We want your story.

Bird photography

Earth Day 2022: Amidst the crises, don’t forget the beauty

Words and images from our founder, Pete Myers, on how bird photography keeps him connected to and curious about a planet in peril.

fracking pennsylvania

Public health in Pennsylvania ignored during fracking rush: Report

A new report outlines the alleged missteps in protecting Pennsylvanians from the health impacts of fracking.

Stay informed: sign up for The Daily Climate newsletter
Top news on climate impacts, solutions, politics, drivers. Delivered to your inbox week days.