opinion
Opinion: Building climate resilience fails to protect human health
The Department of Health and Human Services' focus on climate resilience is insufficient to address the extensive health impacts of climate change.
In short:
- The HHS Climate Action Plan emphasizes resilience without adequately addressing prevention.
- Resilience policies overlook the pervasive and constant health threats posed by climate change.
- The approach may lead to accepting climate disasters as inevitable, rather than preventable.
Key quote:
"Resilience is the categorical imperative of business-as-usual; it is crisis managers buying time. For others, resilience is exhausting."
— Ajay Singh Chaudhary, author of The Exhausted of the Earth.
Why this matters:
Focusing solely on resilience without prevention leaves populations, especially the vulnerable, in perpetual danger. This approach risks normalizing climate disasters instead of aiming to mitigate them.
Relevant EHN coverage:
Opinion: Rethinking utility incentives is key to meeting rising US electricity demands
As electricity demand spikes, a shift from traditional fossil fuel plants to renewable energy sources is critical to avoid compromising U.S. climate objectives.
In short:
- Utilities like Duke Energy plan to build more gas-fired plants to meet rising electricity needs driven by digitalization and electric vehicles.
- Innovative solutions such as virtual power plants and enhanced energy efficiency could meet these demands more sustainably.
- Changes in regulatory frameworks are being tested to incentivize utilities to invest in green technologies.
Key quote:
"We need to electrify everything from cars to appliances to slow climate change, but we won’t be able to reach our climate goals if we power all of those machines with dirty energy."
— Jonathan Mingle, independent journalist and the author of “Gaslight: The Atlantic Coast Pipeline and the Fight for America’s Energy Future”
Why this matters:
As demand for electricity increases, the adoption of sustainable practices and regulatory changes could significantly reduce carbon emissions and foster an equitable, modern electric grid.
Opinion: European court's climate ruling holds lessons for action on plastic pollution
A recent landmark decision by the European Court of Human Rights held Switzerland accountable for inadequate climate policies, specifically highlighting the increased risk of heatwave-related deaths among older women. Plastic production is another case where governments have failed to protect vulnerable groups.
In short:
- The climate case focused on collective rights to a healthy environment.
- The ruling opens avenues for future legal actions against governments for failing to protect public health against environmental hazards.
- Plastic production, involving hazardous chemicals, represents a similar negligence, affecting reproductive health and increasing disease risks.
Key quote:
"This...decision is about the right of groups of people to enjoy a 'healthy environment'."
— Sian Sutherland, co-founder of A Plastic Planet
Why this matters:
The climate case underscores the legal leverage that groups can use against governments that neglect environmental health policies. As negotiators meet in Ottawa this week to move toward agreement on a binding agreement to control plastic pollution, it's a timely message. Here's what to know about the fourth round of plastic treaty talks.
Opinion: Reevaluating our methods in pursuit of environmental sustainability
We need to rethink the effectiveness of focusing solely on decarbonization to achieve true sustainability.
In short:
- Technological solutions like decarbonization might not address the deeper social and political issues affecting environmental sustainability.
- Emphasis on reducing carbon emissions often overshadows other environmental concerns such as biodiversity loss and pollution.
- The current strategy of reducing emissions through technological means may neglect the underlying economic and political factors contributing to environmental degradation.
Key quote:
"Technology can, at best, kick conflicts down the road. Peace cannot be engineered."
— Peter Sutoris, environmental anthropologist
Why this matters:
Relying solely on decarbonization to achieve sustainability overlooks several critical aspects of environmental and societal health. Decarbonization primarily focuses on reducing carbon emissions, particularly from energy production and industrial processes, which is undoubtedly essential. However, sustainability is a broader concept that includes economic, social, and environmental balance.
Opinion: A vacation surprise - when a mosquito bite leads to dengue fever
In a personal recount, Dr. Deborah Heaney shares her unexpected battle with dengue fever following a vacation mosquito bite, highlighting the disease's surge in Latin America and the Caribbean.
In short:
- Dengue fever, often overlooked, caught Dr. Heaney by surprise, revealing gaps in public and medical awareness.
- The disease is proliferating due to climate change, with 2024 poised to set new records in Latin America and the Caribbean.
- Efforts to educate travelers, medical professionals, and the public on dengue fever and its prevention are urgently needed.
Key quote:
"We will be doomed to miss textbook cases like mine."
— Deborah Heaney, physician
Why this matters:
As global temperatures rise, the habitats suitable for mosquitoes are expanding. Warmer climates allow these mosquitoes to survive and breed in regions that were previously too cold for them, including higher altitude areas and more temperate zones. This expansion means that more people are at risk of dengue fever as these mosquitoes bring the disease to new areas.
Exploring solar geoengineering's potential and perils
As the climate crisis deepens, the siren song of solar geoengineering beckons, but the law of unintended consequences looms large.
In short:
- Solar geoengineering, once a taboo subject, is gaining traction as a possible climate change solution, involving strategies like reflecting sunlight via particles in the stratosphere.
- Concerns include the risk of "termination shock" and altering rainfall patterns, highlighting the necessity for global participation in research.
- Recent backlash against outdoor experiments underscores the urgent need for transparency and public engagement in geoengineering discussions.
Key quote:
"I’m increasingly convinced that we should do more research on solar geoengineering. But such high-stakes science requires extraordinary levels of transparency and accountability to the global public."
— Jeremy Freeman, executive director of CarbonPlan, a climate research nonprofit
Why this matters:
With the growing interest in solar geoengineering as a "Band-Aid" for climate change, this essay urges caution and care in navigating the ethical and environmental implications. Ideas to dim the sun 'ignore the root cause' of the climate crisis – and create a cascade of unintended problems, scientists and activists say.
Craig Pittman: Florida officials omit climate change terminology to elude issue recognition
In an attempt to rhetorically negate climate change, Florida legislators are purging the term from state laws, signaling denial rather than action.
In short:
- Florida Representatives propose bills to remove 'climate change' from legal documents, aiming to sidestep the issue.
- This symbolic erasure does nothing to combat the tangible effects of climate change experienced in the state.
- Critics argue this move contradicts efforts by previous Republican administrations that acknowledged and began to address climate change impacts.
Key quote:
“We built [Florida's Climate Future] because we wanted to make it clear to Floridians that we’re already picking up the tab for climate impacts to our state.”
— Dawn Shirreffs, Florida director of Environmental Defense Fund
Why this matters:
Climate change denial in Florida disregards its substantial impacts on public health and safety, symbolizing a broader trend of political evasion that could undermine national efforts to address environmental challenges effectively.
Peter Dykstra: Ten durable, indestructible denial memes that wouldn't be so harmful, except that they're now part of national policy.